What is Credition?
Credition is derived from credere, the Latin word for to believe. The expression credition is formed in the same way as emotion or cognition. Credition [in the singular] refers to the central function of the brain that belief produces belief. Creditions [in the plural form] refers to the processes that give rise to belief. They primarily take place unconsciously (subliminally).
[1] Is it right to think primarily of religion when I say "believe"?
That is a problem. However, it is widespread for people to think of religion first when they here the word “belief”. This is the result of around two thousand years of an intellectual history and is therefore also linked to Christianity.
[3] When do creditions occur?
Creditions can be activated in different situations, e.g. in self-assessment or the assessment of unclear situations. They can occur in very different areas. In addition to those relating to religion, there are also belief processes in the context of politics, technology, climate change, business,leadership behaviour, financial investments - but also in connection with nutrition, health or partnership.
[4] Are creditions important to me personally?
Yes, creditions are activated, for example, when you think about questions of meaning, such as the meaning of life or the importance you attach to your relationship with another person. Creditions influence what and for whom you want to live or what you want to commit yourself to. In addition, creditions play a role in the perception and judgement of other people, as well as in the assessment of one's own abilities. Creditions are also extremely important today because the flood of fake news is causing us to become uncertain and ask ourselves the question: What can we (still) believe?
[5] Can I notice whether and how my own creditions work?
The process of creditions begins outside of conscious perception. The resulting "preconscious ideas" are subliminal and are called primal beliefs . When the "threshold of consciousness" is crossed, we can consciously perceive the attitudes and behaviours generated by creditions. Now they can be recognised and expressed linguistically as "belief that..." or "belief in...". Although creditions are already effective in a subliminal phase, the results of our creditions have a lasting effect on our actions from the moment they become conscious and are verbalised.
[6] What effects do creditions have?
It is not indifferent which beliefs and convictions we develop during the course of creditions. If they are stabilised through metacognitive reflection, they influence our own emotional state and mindset, but especially our actions and behaviour. However, the stability of faith-based beliefs can change again due to new stimuli from the external or internal world. That is of central relevance with regard to religious beliefs (see [10])
[7] Since when have creditions existed?
Around two million years ago, hominids underwent a far-reaching evolutionary development. Their brain development made a huge leap from this point onwards (Iriki & Taoka 2012). It can even be assumed that brain development was also driven forward because the ability to believe emerged in the further course of evolution. For the ability to believe, the brain needed new resources. The emergence of creditions could thus become a driving force of brain development (Seitz & Angel 2020).
However, the topic of credition has only developed into an interdisciplinary field of research in the last decade. At The Structure of Credition 2015 , which was organised at the University of Graz, neurologist Rüdiger J. Seitz postulated that credition is a brain function that plays a key role in the development of our beliefs. This means, among other things, that creditions cannot be switched off. It is therefore not possible to "not believe". This view was first published in 2016 (Angel & Seitz 2016).
The articles mentioned can also be found on this website: https://credition.uni-graz.at/de/creditionenforschung/grundlagenforschung/
[8] What good does it do me if I know about creditions?
We often (but often unconsciously) have certain ideas in the back of our minds that influence our communication. Knowing these is a prerequisite for being able to recognise them when they occur. You can then deal with your own ideas - often referred to as basic beliefs - and, if necessary, work on changing them.
If you have access to the thought patterns that are at the back of your mind, you can also talk about them with others. To do this, it is helpful to refer to models. For example, if you often have the impression in conversations that the other person is pressurising you to do something, you can communicate this well using the so-called communication square ("four-ear model"). It makes communication easier if the other person also recognises the model.
Credition research has developed two models. One is called the neural credition model. It describes processes in the brain that are effective when we develop beliefs. The other is the credition communication model. It can be used in conversations. No neuroscientific knowledge is required to apply it. However, it does make communication easier if everyone involved in a conversation is familiar with the model.
[9] Can the Creditions models also be used professionally?
Yes, the neural credition model helps to understand what is going on inside us as we form our beliefs and how this affects our actions. It can also help us understand that creditions can cause clinical disorders that lead to abnormal beliefs.
You can refer to the credition communication model if you have a lot to do with communication in your job and want to analyse and better understand your own and others' communication behaviour.
[2] Do creditions have anything to do with religion?
No. Creditions are biological processes. They have nothing to do with religion, although their occurrence in connection with religious belief is particularly striking (see [10] to [14]). However, they play a role in all types of belief. That is why they occur very frequently overall.
[10] What influence do creditions have on religious belief?
Creditions are involved when religious belief arises. They have an influence on whether religious belief grows, declines or is completely lost. However, the word religious can be misleading.
[11] What do you mean by religious?
Religious semantics is confusing.
(1) There are two SUBSTANTIVES that must be clearly distinguished from each other: Religion and religiosity.
Then there is the ADJECTIVE religious. It is bipolarbecause it can refer to both nouns. And it is a connecting adjective that refers to the relationship of religion and religiosity. When you use the adjective religious, you should therefore express the fact that it both about religion as well as religiosity. Unfortunately, this distinction is not usually made in our culture.
(2) In general as well as in scientific usage, the adjective religious is rather amputated because it usually refers exclusively to religion . This mutilation has a negative effect because the religious semantics are now one-sided and wrongly weighted and wrongly weighted. This can even be dangerous, for example when talking about religious extremism and referring to a religion.
(3) Religion(s) are about cultural systems. Religiosity is about persons or individuals. If the characterisation religious is applied to individuals, then it is about the "manifestation of religiosity". For example, you can analyse which religious behaviour goes hand in hand with the expression of religiosity .
[12] What do we mean by religiosity?
In psychology, this refers to a personality trait. However, this is not stable. People's individual religiosity can change profoundly over the course of their lives. The surrounding culture plays a role in this. Different religions can also provide different impulses that have an impact on the development of individual or collective religiosity .
But now comes something really crazy: there are a myriad of theoretical proposals on how to define religion . However, there are hardly any attempts to theoretically clarify what we mean by religiosity . This is why the word "religiosity" is often used in the general language of our culture as well as in science, theology or religious education, without any precise idea of what is meant by it.
As long as everyone does this, it is hardly noticeable. In reality, however, such linguistic behaviour is really blatant. However, there is no need to resign oneself to this nebulous indifference. We can certainly try to gain a better theoretical understanding of human religiosity . Even if we are still on relatively uncertain ground for the time being, a hypothetical question can be posed: Could it be that religiosity is something like an extended homeostasis system (homeostasis II) that helps to keep human life in balance? Just as the biological homeostasis system(homeostasis I) is able to compensate for changes (such as temperature differences), the homeostasis system II can react to challenges or changes that shake our previous sense of meaning or our previous idea of transcendence.
Religiosity as an extended hypostasis system: The proposal to understand religiosity as a kind of "balance system" that gives people support and stability despite all distress or uncertainty (Angel 2006, 69-91) was a decisive impulse for the beginning of credition research(Angel 2022).
[13] Religiosity as an extended homeostasis system
Attempts at definition are still on relatively uncertain ground for the time being. One suggestion is to understand religiosity as an extended homeostasis system that gives people support and stability despite all distress or uncertainty (Angel 2006, 69-91).
Just as the biological homeostasis system(homeostasis I) is able to compensate for changes (such as temperature differences), religiosity would then be understood as an extended homeostasis system (homeostasis II) would be able to react to challenges or changes that shake previous answers to finding meaning or previous ideas about transcendence.
Understanding religiosity in this sense as a kind of "balance system" was a decisive impulse for the beginning of credition research(Angel 2022).
[14] Do creditions play a role in the development of religiosity?
Yes, traditions play a central role in shaping human religiosity. They influence the way in which individuals relate to a religion and this has an impact on how they characterise their religiosity . The individual manifestations of religiosity(e.g. cosmopolitan, narrow-minded, patriarchal, reconciliatory, fundamentalist, etc.) can vary widely. This can even be the case when people refer to the same religion. However, the individual manifestations of religiosity can also be close to each other, even if people refer to different religions.
[15] Why are creditions so important for religious belief?
If we make a clear distinction between religion and religiosity, we can recognise this: Religious belief can always arise when someone develops their own individual religiosity with reference to a religion (including its current social or political context). People can deal with religions in different ways. They can adopt or reject all or individual components of religions. Creditions have an influence on whether and how this happens. They contribute to the fact that even within the same religion there are different forms of individual religiosity. If you want to understand why there are similarities in religious behaviour across the boundaries of religions and you want to reduce the tension between religions, it is helpful to understand creditions. The same applies if you want to know why there are such big differences in religious behaviour within one and the same religion . Here too, creditions are one of the decisive factors. If you want to contribute to dealing constructively with these differences or to resolve them, knowledge of creditions is a great advantage,
Head of the Credition Research Project
| https://aljoschaneubauer.wordpress.com/ |
| https://www.tugraz.at/institute/ime/home |
| bit.ly/431NU0C |
Overall scientific planning
Prof Dr Hans-Ferdinand Angel
Academic biography:
1976 -1981 Studied Latin, theology, history in Regensburg and Paris
1982 - 1984 Teaching at the humanistic grammar school Leopoldinum in Passau and at the humanistic-new language grammar school in Kelheim
1984 - 1988 Doctorate in Religious Education at the University of Regensburg (Prof. Dr Wolfgang Nastainczyk): Topic: Science and technology in religious education
1988 - 1994 Habilitation in religious education at the University of Regensburg (Prof. Dr Wolfgang Nastainczyk): Topic: The religious person in times of catastrophe. Religious education perspectives on collective phenomena of misery
1994 - 1996 Private lecturer at the University of Regensburg
1996 - 1997 Professorship for Religious Education at the TU Dresden
1997 - 2023 Professorship for Catechetics and Religious Education at the Karl-Franzens University of Graz
2011 Scientific director of the Credition Research Project
2023 Professor emeritus of the Karl-Franzens University of Graz
https://religionspaedagogik.uni-graz.at/de/persoenlichkeiten/
Prof Dr Rüdiger J. Seitz
https://klinikum-duesseldorf.lvr.de/de/nav_main/vita/vita_5.html